Screw it, I'm in.
Before: I'd be the lone human looking rather confused at being surrounded by real furries. Brown hair, gray eyes, pale-ish white skin befitting a nerd who never steps outside. Red t-shirt and jeans and black shoes. The food item would be a exotic cooked worm/larva looking thing
After: Rough-skinned newt. Bipedal, but still *looking* more feral than anthro (short legs and the like). Should be rather purple-ish in hue like the following ref appears. Twisting head around backward in shock to catch a glimpse of large, long new tail that's burst out the back and ripped apart the pants (general ripped clothing here is a plus).
(dunno what the actual color is, but it looks rather purplish
and that's what I'd like to see)
Also, voting for Keetah as well